Carleton College vs Hillsdale College

  • Carleton College admits a smaller share of applicants (20% vs 21% at Hillsdale College).
  • Hillsdale College has a higher six-year graduation rate (89% vs 89% at Carleton College).
  • Carleton College is larger (2,086 undergraduates vs 1,573 undergraduates at Hillsdale College).
Carleton CollegeHillsdale College
LocationNorthfield, MNHillsdale, MI
TypePrivate nonprofitPrivate nonprofit
Acceptance rate20%21%
SAT (middle 50%)1450–15601320–1490
ACT (middle 50%)32–3430–33
Undergraduates2,0861,573
Cost of attendance$89,204—
Average net price$25,295—
Graduation rate89%89%
Deadlines 2026-27Early Decision: Nov 15, 2026Early Decision II: Jan 15, 2027Regular Decision: Jan 15, 2027Early Decision: Nov 1, 2026Regular Decision: Mar 15, 2027
Supplemental prompts1 prompts3 prompts

Numbers: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard, most recent release. Deadlines and prompts from each college's official admissions site.

Applying to both?

Admit Coach tracks both deadlines, sets up every prompt and groups the ones you can answer with the same essay.

Start free