Compare

A Kolly alternative for college essay feedback

Kolly and Admit Coach both score college essays on six dimensions and help you plan your applications. They differ most on price, how much you can do free, and how much writing the AI does for you. Here's a fair comparison.

At a glance

Admit CoachKolly
Free essay grading3 grades a day, no accountOne full review
Monthly plan$12 a month$29 a month
Six-month plan$49 per 6 months$99 per 6 months
One-time pass, no renewal$49 Season PassNot listed
Parent can pay with a linkYesYes
AI rewrites and draftingNo: one-sentence edits you approveParagraph rewrites and drafting
Deadlines and prompts1,900+ collegesYes
Activities and honors reviewYesYes, plus letters of recommendation
Scholarship finderNoYes
Library of accepted essaysNoYes

Kolly details from Kolly's pricing page, checked November 2026. Prices and features can change.

Less than half the price

Admit Coach Pro is $12 a month or $49 for a six-month season. Kolly lists $29 a month or $99 for six months. If you'd rather not have a subscription at all, Admit Coach's Season Pass is a one-time $49 for the season that doesn't renew, and a parent can pay for it from a private link.

Grade more essays free

Kolly's free plan includes one full review. Admit Coach's free grader gives up to 3 grades a day without an account, and a free account adds a full review with line notes, the coach and deadline planning. That's enough to work through a personal statement and a few supplements before deciding whether to pay.

A coach that won't write it for you

Kolly offers paragraph rewrites and help drafting. Admit Coach deliberately doesn't: its coach suggests one small edit at a time, built from your words, and refuses to ghostwrite. If you want help that keeps every sentence yours, that's the point of Admit Coach.

Where Kolly does more

Kolly has features Admit Coach doesn't: a scholarship and summer program finder, a library of essays from admitted students, reviews of letters of recommendation and a per-school mock admissions committee. If those matter to you, Kolly may be worth the higher price.

When Kolly might be the better pick

  • You want to read essays from admitted students alongside your own.
  • You want a scholarship and summer program finder in the same app.
  • You want AI help drafting or rewriting whole paragraphs.

How the grader reads your essay

Each draft gets a 1–5 score on six things admissions readers weigh. Every score quotes the lines that earned it, the weakest one is flagged, and you get the one change that would help most. The same draft always gets the same score.

Hook
Does the opening make a reader want the next line?
Theme
Is there one clear idea the essay is about?
Detail
Are there specific moments, names and objects, not summaries?
Authenticity
Does it sound like a real 17-year-old, in your voice?
Reflection
Does it show how you think and what changed?
Writing
Is it clear, tight and correct?

Frequently asked questions

If you want honest essay scores and coaching for less, Admit Coach is the closest alternative: the same six scoring dimensions, a free grader with 3 grades a day, and Pro for $12 a month or $49 per six months.

Yes. Admit Coach Pro is $12 a month or $49 per six months, versus $29 a month or $99 per six months for Kolly (as listed on Kolly's pricing page).

No. Admit Coach and Kolly are separate, independent products.

Yes. Grade up to 3 essays a day with no account, or create a free account for a full review, the coach and deadline planning.

See how your essay scores

Six scores against an admissions rubric, quotes from your draft as evidence, and the one fix to make next. Free, no account needed.

Grade for a specific school

Each school page has that college's supplemental prompts built in, so you can grade a draft against the exact question.

Every school's essay prompts