Keuka College vs St. John Fisher University

  • St. John Fisher University admits a smaller share of applicants (66% vs 68% at Keuka College).
  • St. John Fisher University has a lower average net price ($29,743 vs $35,459 at Keuka College).
  • St. John Fisher University has a higher six-year graduation rate (74% vs 49% at Keuka College).
  • St. John Fisher University is larger (2,565 undergraduates vs 966 undergraduates at Keuka College).
Keuka CollegeSt. John Fisher University
LocationKeuka Park, NYRochester, NY
TypePrivate nonprofitPrivate nonprofit
Acceptance rate68%66%
SAT (middle 50%)—1120–1300
ACT (middle 50%)—23–28
Undergraduates9662,565
Cost of attendance$57,493$57,224
Average net price$35,459$29,743
Graduation rate49%74%
Deadlines 2026-27Check the college's siteEarly Decision: Dec 1, 2026
Supplemental promptsNone on fileNone on file

Numbers: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard, most recent release. Deadlines and prompts from each college's official admissions site.

Applying to both?

Admit Coach tracks both deadlines, sets up every prompt and groups the ones you can answer with the same essay.

Start free