Testing · 7 min read ·
Should I Submit My SAT or ACT Scores? Test-Optional Guide
Should I submit my SAT or ACT scores? Compare your score to each college's middle 50% range, weigh other factors and follow a simple test-optional rule.

Should I submit my SAT or ACT scores? At a test-optional college, submit your score if it's at or above the middle of that college's middle 50% range, and consider withholding it if it's below the 25th percentile. In between, it depends on the rest of your application, and every policy should be confirmed on the college's own admissions site, because policies differ and change.
This guide explains the policy types, how to read a middle 50% range, a simple decision table, a worked example with real ranges and the other factors that can change your answer.
Test-optional, test-required, test-blind: what each policy means
| Policy | What it means | Your decision |
|---|---|---|
| Test-required | You must submit an SAT or ACT score | Submit your best score |
| Test-optional | You choose whether to submit; applications without scores are reviewed too | Compare your score to the college's range |
| Test-flexible | Other tests, such as AP or IB scores, may substitute | Read which tests count |
| Test-blind or test-free | Scores aren't considered even if you send them | Don't submit |
Colleges change these policies, sometimes from one cycle to the next. Some also have exceptions for certain programs, homeschooled students or international applicants. Always confirm the current policy on each college's official admissions page before deciding.
What is the SAT and ACT middle 50%?
The middle 50% is the range between the 25th and 75th percentile scores of enrolled first-year students who submitted scores.
- 25th percentile: a quarter of those students scored at or below this number.
- 75th percentile: a quarter scored at or above it.
- Inside the range: half of the students who submitted scores.
You can find each college's range on its Admit Coach profile, which uses federal College Scorecard data. Three examples:
| College | SAT middle 50% | ACT middle 50% |
|---|---|---|
| University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1380–1520 | 29–33 |
| Purdue University | 1200–1480 | 27–34 |
| University of Texas at Austin | 1250–1510 | 27–33 |
The SAT figures in Scorecard data add the reading and math section percentiles, so treat them as approximate composite ranges.
Should I submit my SAT or ACT scores? A simple rule
Compare your score to each college's range, then use this table. The "midpoint" is halfway between the 25th and 75th percentiles. It's a rough guide, not the true median.
| Your score | At a test-optional college |
|---|---|
| At or above the 75th percentile | Submit |
| Between the midpoint and the 75th percentile | Usually submit |
| Between the 25th percentile and the midpoint | It depends; see the factors below |
| Below the 25th percentile | Usually withhold, unless another factor applies |
This is a strategy guide, not a formula colleges use. Your grades, courses and essays matter more than any single number.
Worked example: one score, three decisions
Here's an illustrative example. A student has a 1410 SAT and is applying to the three colleges above. Suppose, for this example, that each is test-optional for her (she'd confirm that on each college's site).
| College | Range | Midpoint | Where 1410 falls | Likely decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| UW–Madison | 1380–1520 | 1450 | Between 25th and midpoint | Depends on other factors |
| Purdue | 1200–1480 | 1340 | Above midpoint | Submit |
| UT Austin | 1250–1510 | 1380 | Above midpoint | Submit |
The same score can be a good submission at one college and a borderline one at another. That's why you decide college by college.
Other factors that can change the answer
The table is a starting point. These can push a borderline score either way:
- Your school context. If your score is high for your high school, it may stand out more than the college's range suggests. Your counselor can tell you how scores at your school compare.
- Your intended major. For math-heavy programs, a strong math section can be useful evidence even if your total is mid-range.
- Your grades. If your GPA is strong, a mid-range score adds less. If your grades are uneven, a strong score can reassure readers about your academic readiness.
- Your coursework. If your school offers few advanced courses, a score can add evidence of readiness.
- Merit scholarships and honors programs. Some colleges use scores for these even when admission is test-optional. Confirm on each college's scholarship page.
- Homeschool or nontraditional transcripts. Scores can give readers a common reference point.
What about AP and IB scores?
AP and IB exam scores can add academic evidence, especially when you're not sending an SAT or ACT. Some colleges let you self-report them in the application, and test-flexible colleges may accept them in place of the SAT or ACT. Strong scores in subjects related to your intended major are the most useful.
Like SAT and ACT policies, how colleges use AP and IB scores varies. Check each college's testing or application instructions before deciding what to report.
Applying to colleges with different policies
Most students apply to a mix: some colleges that require scores, some that are test-optional and maybe one that doesn't consider them. That's fine. You can submit scores where they help and withhold them where they don't.
The practical challenge is keeping track. Applications may handle this differently, and some colleges ask in their own questions whether you want your scores considered. Read each college's section of the application carefully, follow its instructions and double-check what you've reported before you submit.
How to find a college's middle 50%
Start with the college's profile on Admit Coach, which shows SAT and ACT middle 50% ranges from federal College Scorecard data. Many colleges also publish testing ranges on their admissions sites or in their Common Data Set, a standard report many schools post each year. Ranges can differ slightly between sources because they cover different years or groups of students, so use the most recent official figure you can find.
SAT or ACT: which should you send?
Send the one that sits higher in the college's range. Look at where your SAT falls in the SAT range and where your ACT falls in the ACT range, and choose the stronger position.
If you need to compare the two tests directly, use the official SAT-ACT concordance tables published by the College Board and ACT. Most colleges accept either test equally; check the admissions page if you're unsure.
Superscoring and Score Choice
Two terms to know:
- Superscoring means a college combines your best section scores across test dates into a new total. If a college superscores, multiple attempts can help.
- Score Choice lets you pick which test dates to send to colleges that allow it. Some colleges ask for all scores.
Policies vary by college and by test. Check each college's testing page before you send scores or decide whether to retake.
Should you retake the SAT or ACT?
A retake makes sense when:
- Your score is just below the midpoint for several colleges on your list.
- You have time to prepare before your deadlines and score reporting windows.
- Your practice scores are noticeably higher than your official score.
It probably isn't worth it if you're already above the 75th percentile at most of your colleges, or if prep time would come out of your essays. Strong essays and a well-written application help at every college, with or without a score.
How to report scores
Colleges handle reporting differently. Some let you self-report scores in the application and send official scores only if you enroll; others want official score reports from the testing agency. Confirm each college's method on its admissions site, and allow time for official reports to arrive before deadlines.
If you're applying early, testing and reporting deadlines come sooner. See our Early Decision vs Early Action guide and the 2026–27 deadlines guide.
Your test score decision checklist
- I confirmed each college's current testing policy on its official site
- I compared my score to each college's 25th and 75th percentiles
- I checked whether each college superscores or uses Score Choice
- I checked whether scores matter for merit aid or honors programs
- I asked my counselor how my score compares at my school
- I recorded submit, withhold or retake for each college
If you're withholding scores, the rest of your application carries more weight, and your essays are the part you still control. Paste your personal essay into the free essay grader to see how it scores on hook, theme, detail, authenticity, reflection and writing.
Frequently asked questions
It depends on how your score compares to each college's range. If your score is at or above the middle of the college's middle 50% range, submitting usually helps. If it's below the 25th percentile at a test-optional school, withholding is often the better choice. Make the decision college by college, not once for your whole list.
It's the range between the 25th and 75th percentile scores of enrolled students who submitted scores. A 25th percentile of 1300 means a quarter of those students scored 1300 or lower, and a 75th percentile of 1480 means a quarter scored 1480 or higher. Half of the students who submitted fall within the range.
Test-optional colleges say they review applications without scores fairly, and you should take each college's official statement at its word. Without a score, readers rely more on your grades, course rigor, essays and recommendations. Read each college's own explanation of its policy on its admissions site, since details differ and policies can change.
Send whichever is stronger relative to the college's range. Compare each score's position against the college's SAT and ACT middle 50% ranges, or use the official SAT-ACT concordance tables to compare them directly. If both are similar, you can usually send one. Check whether the college superscores either test before deciding.
Sometimes. Some colleges consider test scores for merit scholarships or honors programs even when admission is test-optional, and others don't use scores at all. This varies widely, so check each college's scholarship page and its financial aid office. If merit aid matters to your family, confirm the policy before deciding to withhold a score.
Get honest feedback on your essay
Six scores against an admissions rubric, quotes from your draft as evidence, and the one fix to make next. Free, no account needed.
Keep reading

Essays · 6 min read
AI vs Human College Essay Review: Which Should You Use?
AI review is instant, consistent and cheap. A good human reader knows you and catches what a model can't. The strongest essays usually get both, at different stages.

Essays · 6 min read
Can Colleges Tell If You Used AI on Your Essay?
AI detectors are unreliable, but that isn't the point. AI-written essays tend to read as generic, policies treat them as misrepresentation, and the safe uses of AI are easy to stay within.

Essays · 7 min read
How AI College Essay Graders Work (and What They Can't Do)
An AI essay grader is a language model plus a rubric, rules and checks. Here's what happens when you paste a draft, why some tools give you a different grade every time, and what no grader can tell you.